Commodore Resort, Put-in-Bay ~ Reviews, Room Choices & Prices 2025

Book with us

Up to 10% cheaper

than on Booking.com

Key details

About the Resort

272 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States

Commodore Resort stands out as the only hotel on the downtown strip of Put-in-Bay, offering unique access to island nightlife. Located merely a block from the downtown ferry, it facilitates convenient access to local bars and attractions. The resort features the Number 1 Pool Bar on the island, enhancing its magnetic charm. With a layout that includes luxury and budget-friendly accommodations, it caters to diverse traveler needs.

Location

Situated in the heart of Put-in-Bay's entertainment district, the resort is seconds away from nightlife and local attractions. The Commodore Resort requires alternate transportation since it is set on an island and is easily accessible by ferry or boat. Nearby landmarks, such as the Butterfly House and DeRivera Park, enrich the surrounding area's leisure options.

Rooms

The Commodore Resort provides various types of accommodations, including King Jacuzzi rooms, rooms for larger groups, and standard rooms with double beds. Each room type ensures comfort with features like private bathrooms, air conditioning, and flat-screen TVs. Guests can enjoy either poolside views or a more private experience with rooms that have exterior corridors.

Eat & Drink

The resort is home to notable dining venues, including Mr. Ed's Bar & Grille and a late-night Subway. Guests can indulge in American cuisine and enjoy meals poolside or in the casual dining atmosphere. The culinary options at the resort cater to various tastes and dining preferences.

Leisure & Business

Commodore Resort offers a vibrant pool area featuring MIST Pool, a celebrated swim-up bar serving handcrafted cocktails. Guests have access to lounge chairs, cabanas, and a seasonal outdoor swimming pool. Nighttime entertainment is also provided by the onsite nightclub, ensuring a lively atmosphere.

View all

Select your room type

The resort provides a range of accommodations, including double rooms, family rooms, and suites, all with breakfast, free cancellations, and exclusive deals.

Two Double Beds Exterior Door Non-Smoking

Max:

4 persons

21 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Two Double Beds Exterior Door Smoking

Max:

4 persons

21 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

King Room Spa Bath Non-Smoking

Max:

2 persons

28 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Explore available ways to reach your dream destination

City Centre

Put-in-Bay200 m

Airports

Toledo Express (TOL) 117.0 km

Cleveland Hopkins International (CLE) 124.3 km

Facilities

Enjoy a range of amenities at the resort designed for your comfortable stay and remarkable experiences.

Spacious Refrigeration!

“The large refrigerator in our room made it easy to store our snacks and drinks for a fun weekend, accommodating our group perfectly.” view full review

Refreshing Pool Fun!

“The Mist pool was a blast! The bartenders were quick and friendly, making our poolside experience truly enjoyable.” view full review

Lobby Convenience!

“Having a Subway in the lobby was incredibly convenient for quick meals and snacks, perfect for our busy schedule.” view full review

Stylish and Clean!

“I loved the modern vinyl wood flooring in our room—so much better than old carpeting! Everything felt fresh and stylish.” view full review

General

Non-smoking rooms
Wi-Fi
No parking
24-hour reception
No pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
24-hour security
Adults only
Luggage storage
Locker room
Lift
ATM/Cash machine
Vending machines
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key card access

Sports & Fitness

Golf course
Fishing

Services

Housekeeping
Tours/Ticket assistance
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Poolside snack bar
Picnic area/ Tables

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Facilities for people with disabilities

Toilet for disabled

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Sun loungers
Live entertainment
Night club
Sun terrace
Leisure/ TV room
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Garden furniture

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

272 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States

Map view

272 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States

City landmarks

Monument

Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial

750 m

808 Langram Rd

Stonehenge Estate

1.2 km

Put in Bay

Perry's Cave

1.0 km

820 Catawba Ave

Chocolate Museum

690 m

Put in Bay

Aquatic Resource Center

610 m

Put in Bay

Alaskan Birdhouse Wildlife Museum

610 m

979 Catawba Ave

Perry's Cave Family Fun Center

1.1 km

Bayview Avenue

Oak Point State Park

1.1 km

Botanical Garden

Butterfly House

1.1 km

Island

South Bass Island

1.8 km

Southern tip of South Bass Island

South Bass Island Lighthouse

1.9 km

East Pont

Scheeff East Point Preserve

1.7 km

Island

Middle Bass Island

3.3 km

1719 Fox Road

Middle Bass Island State Park

2.5 km

Starve Island

2.9 km

Winery

Lonz Winery

3.3 km

Bass Islands

3.5 km

Nearby

2 Bayside Ave

DeRivera Park

460 m

Restaurants

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

420 m

439 Loraine Ave

Candy Bar

480 m

170 Delaware St

Village Bakery and Cafe

620 m

104 Delaware St

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience. <br />

66%

liked the resort and would come back

6.6/10

Nice

Rooms

5.0

Location

9.2

Service

5.4

Dining

7.0

Neil

United States, January 2025

8.0/10

I had a mixed experience at the Commodore. While I enjoyed the lively atmosphere and the energetic vibe around the pool area, the noise levels were quite high, making it hard to sleep. On the bright side, the staff was very responsive and accommodating, especially when I had to leave early due to a storm. Just be prepared for a party vibe rather than a peaceful retreat.

Rooms

7.0

The room was basic but comfortable, though I was disappointed that it wasn't the poolside view I expected and also lacked a hairdryer.

Service

8.0

The service was attentive and accommodating. The staff handled my early checkout smoothly and ensured I had what I needed during my stay.

Location

9.0

The location is unbeatable, right in the heart of the action with everything you need within walking distance, making it easy to explore Put-In-Bay.

Dining

Facilities

8.0

The pool area was definitely the highlight, filled with energy and plenty of opportunities for socializing, but it was a bit too crowded at times.

Joseph

United States, October 2024

6.6/10

I had a mixed experience at this hotel. While the location is spot-on for enjoying the local nightlife, the room I stayed in was quite outdated and not very pleasant. The energy of the pool area was fun and vibrant, perfect for party-goers. However, I faced issues with cleanliness and overall maintenance, which left me wanting more from my stay.

Rooms

5.0

The room was outdated and had a musty smell with some maintenance issues.

Service

6.0

The staff were friendly and tried to help, but there were some frustrating delays in service.

Location

9.0

The hotel is right in the center of all the fun, perfect for nightlife activities.

Dining

7.0

The dining options were limited but having a Subway in the lobby was convenient.

Facilities

7.0

The pool area was lively and a great place to socialize, but it could use better maintenance.

Daniel

United States, October 2024

5.8/10

My stay at the Commodore had its ups and downs. While the lively pool area was a lot of fun and we enjoyed having a Subway conveniently located in the lobby, we faced some serious issues with room cleanliness and service. Overall, it felt like a decent option for a weekend party vibe, but definitely not for a longer stay or if you're looking for a quiet getaway.

Rooms

5.0

While one room was cleaner, the other had some significant hygiene issues, like dried puke and cobwebs. The overall atmosphere in the rooms felt outdated.

Service

5.0

The customer service was lacking, particularly with a staff member named Kelly who didn't provide the best support. It felt frustrating at times.

Location

9.0

The location is perfect for party life, easily accessible to bars and entertainment, making it a great base for a fun trip.

Dining

7.0

Having Subway in the lobby was convenient, especially after a long day of exploring.

Facilities

6.0

The pool area was vibrant and lively, but it could use some better maintenance, especially with so many partygoers around.

Luther

United States, September 2024

6.2/10

The Commodore Hotel has a great location right in the middle of everything, making it easy to access bars and restaurants. While the lively atmosphere was a blast for our group, the rooms left a lot to be desired, with inconsistent quality and some cleanliness issues. The pool area was bustling, which added to the fun, but service could be snappy and hit or miss, especially on busy weekends.

Rooms

5.0

The rooms were quite inconsistent and not as clean as I hoped. Some had outdated furniture, and I noticed some cleanliness issues like a spider in my bed and hair in the shower.

Service

5.0

Service during our stay was inconsistent; while some staff were helpful, others seemed annoyed by our questions.

Location

9.0

The location is fantastic, just steps away from the main strip and very convenient for nightlife and dining.

Dining

Facilities

7.0

The pool area was very lively and perfect for socializing, but I was disappointed it wasn't heated and could get overcrowded quickly.

James

United States, August 2024

6.8/10

The Commodore is in an excellent location for anyone looking to enjoy the nightlife of Put-In-Bay; being close to everything is a definite perk. The pool area has a vibrant atmosphere that's perfect for socializing and having fun. However, my room had a strong smell of cigarette smoke, which really took away from the experience, and it was disappointing that housekeeping only cleaned our room once during our stay. Overall, it’s got a lively vibe, but some aspects could use improvement.

Rooms

5.0

Unfortunately, the room had a strong smell of cigarette smoke that lingered throughout our stay.

Service

5.0

The service was decent when we needed something, but I wish housekeeping had been more attentive, especially with so many of us in the room.

Location

10.0

The location was fantastic, right in the middle of all the entertainment, which made getting around super easy.

Dining

Facilities

8.0